FanEx Analysis Draft
Round 12

Rules | Transactions

Draft Rounds - See below for analysis
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20  
Final Analysis

 12.01
Tony Holm
QB Tarvaris Jackson
QB: Young  Rodgers Jackson  RB: Grant Parker McFadden JJones Fargas 
 
WR: RMoss Holmes Cotchery Berrian TE: PK:  DT:

I hemmed and hawed with this pick.  I looked at TE, another RB, WR and the remaining QBs.  As I was the last FAD team to draft my #1 QB, I had decided that I would be trotting out 3 QBs already and there's not much left that I feel are valuable picks so eventually pulled the trigger on Jackson.  JaMarcus Russell was also a consideration here.  Ultimately I like that Jackson is in his third year with the Vikings and has experience in 2007 having played in 12 games.  He has shown signs of progress and the Vikings have added a few more receivers like Bernard Berrian and it doesn't hurt that defenses will be focused on Adrian Peterson and not Tarvaris Jackson.  Jackson has looked sharp in training camp and his new familiarity with the offense has shown as he's making much quicker reads and is throwing the ball with confidence.  He should post some decent numbers given the offense that he is running and I hope my three headed QB machine will be scoring some good base points for me all season long.
===================================================================================

12.02
Matt Pitzer
RB Warrick Dunn 

QB: Hasselbeck Roethlisberger RB: Barber Bush BJackson Dunn
WR CJohnson Holt Curtis Clayton
TE: Watson  PK:  DT:

Just adding more depth at running back with a guy who could emerge as a starter even though Dunn really returned to Tampa Bay only to wrap up his career. He has been very durable late in his career and the Bucs could use a regular presence at running back. He also is a good receiver and if that leads to a few nice games, I'll take that production.
===================================================================================

12.03

Greg Kellogg
QB Alex Smith 

QB: Romo Leinart ASmith  RB: Portis RBrown Henry FJones Norwood  
WR:
Marshal Evans Driver DCarter TE: PK:  DT:

It was always my intent to have three quarterbacks but I had hoped that Tarvaris Jackson would fall to me.  Since that was the case I was left with a decision between a quarterback that is unhappy with his contract, Jeff Garcia, and one that might lose his job, Alex Smith.  I opted for Smith because I believe he will continue to be the starter in San Francisco and if Mike Martz can turn Jon Kitna into a fantasy stud, it is likely he will do the same with Smith.
===================================================================================

12.04

Duane Cahill
RB Ricky Williams 

QB: Brady RB: LJohnson Graham Mendenhall McAllister CBrown RWilliams
WR: Boldin Bowe Jennings Bruce Stallworth
TE: PK:  DT:
Look no further than our first round to get a sense of how essential the RB position is in this league. 

I've had the opportunity to see Ricky a couple of times this off-season and it certainly appears that his issues are behind him.  He has a clear cut plan to play 2-3 more seasons and then get out and move on with his life. While I don't believe he has a burning desire to play football, he understands that the game is the gateway to the next phase of his life.   And that may well be enough motivation.  He's an interesting cat. 

It looks like he's going to wind up splitting touches with Ronnie Brown, and while my roster looks to have several backs in these tandems, I fully expect my quantity to hide the blemish of not carrying two bona fide studs.

===================================================================================
12.05
Ian Allan
WR Bryant Johnson 

QB: Cutler Garrard  RB: SJackson Forte KSmith Bradshaw
WR: AJohnson SSmith Welker CJohnson BrJohnson
TE: Davis PK:  DT:

I have four wide receivers I really like — Andre Johnson, Steve Smith, Wes Welker and Calvin Johnson — but all of those guys are going to have byes and multiple weeks with poor stats, so there’s certainly room for another wide receiver. I’ve opted to go light at the running back position, so I’ll be playing four wide receivers virtually every week. Bryant Johnson, I think, might be pretty good. I think he’ll be the top pass catcher in San Francisco, and I expect the 49ers to throw the ball a lot this season (with Mike Martz taking over as their offensive coordinator).
===================================================================================

12.06

Chris Dolfi | Tom Walls
WR DJ Hackett 

QB: Anderson  RB: Lynch Jones-Drew Jacobs
WR: Housh Coles Crayton Hackett
TE: Winslow Heap  PK: DT:

We can honestly say that WR was the position we were LEAST looking at with this selection.  In this case, we simply thought the RB talent too thin to pass up a value pick like Hackett at this spot. 

Hackett was given assurances by the Panthers that he'll be the #2 WR on the squad this year, and any WR opposite Steve Smith isn't going to see much double coverage - we like the sound of that.  Toss in the fact that Hackett is the tall possession receiver in contrast to the smaller, faster Smith and we think Hackett will get a few looks in the redzone.  Injured last year, he still managed 6 TDs in the 6 games he played in - a scoring trend we'd love to see continue into 2008.  Even with Hackett's injury history, he simply had too much upside for us to ignore this late in the draft.

===================================================================================

12.07

Shannon O'Leary 
RB DeShaun Foster

QB: Bulger Delhomme RB: Gore Lewis RJohnson Bell Foster
WR: Fitzgerald White Walker Porter
TE: Gonzalez  PK:  DT:
Foster is a capable runner who, like a lot of running backs in the NFL, has a problem staying healthy. As I said in the 1st round, I would look at Foster later in the draft. I have handcuffed him and Gore. Gore has a long list of injuries himself, so having Foster was an insurance pick. Foster’s yard’s per carry were down last year, but that could be attributed to the lack of a solid QB for the Panthers last year.  Of course that could be a concern in San Fran this year. Ultimately I am hoping Gore takes care of business and I don’t need points from Foster. This is Foster’s 6th year in the league, so he should have something in the tank, and is an upgrade over last years back ups.
===================================================================================

12.08

Jim Butler
RB TJ Duckett

QB: Brees Schaub Rivers  RB: McGahee White Duckett 
WR: Galloway Sweed DJackson Glenn
TE: Gates Cooley   PK: DT:
With Seattle retooling their entire backfield in the off season, I just don't see Julius Jones being the goal line back there. This bodes well for Duckett. I don't see a lot of yards coming from T.J. but TDs should be a plenty. One of the weaker areas of the Seahawks last season was running the ball inside the 10 yard line and I think T.J. was brought in to fix that.
===================================================================================

12.09

John Georgopoulos
WR Darrell Jackson

QB: EManning Edwards  RB: Westbrook TJones DWilliams Betts 
WR: Wayne Colston Ward Branch DJackson TE: PK:  DT:
This is where I like to take some shots at veterans with question marks... Jackson certainly fits that bill. But if he's healthy, he can put up very solid, if unspectacular, numbers playing opposite Marshall.
===================================================================================

12.10

Jerome Hickerson
RB Ray Rice (R)

QB: Palmer Campbell  RB: Addai Maroney  Taylor CJohnson Rice
WR: Edwards Harrison Gonzales RBrown TE: Shockey PK:  DT:
I’m not a fan of taking a bunch of rookies, but I grabbed my second rookie RB here because I see this guy as an interesting talent backing up a guy who does get injured and misses time. While I believe Rice has value from the start as a 3rd down back, I also think he has a decent shot at significant playing time behind McGahee. Evaluating rookies comes down to opportunity and talent and I see this guy as having some of both.
===================================================================================

12.11

TC Cannon
DT Chargers

QB: PManning RB: Peterson Stewart Benson Young 
 
WR: Owens Burress Chambers Engram Hardy TE: Clark  PK:  DT: Chargers
Rather than claiming a positive alternative TE2, I decided to continue my dependence on TE Clark and claim the most popular DT -- the Chargers. In 2007, they were the most productive in this scoring format. Yet, even then, the difference between SD and others was minor - a few points each week. The thought is to have two of the better DTs, taking advantage of the best-ball format.
===================================================================================

12.12

Chris Rito | Mike Nazarek
TE TJ Smith

QB: Anderson McNabb Kitna  RB: Lynch Jones-Drew Jacobs CTaylor 
WR: Housh Mason Burleson Gaffney
TE: Winslow Smith PK:  DT:
We are at the point where some folks might be taking backup TEs, and there are a couple left on the board that are in our top 10 (even though 12 TEs have been drafted). Smith is finally healthy and is in a contract year, so we hope those two factors make him a solid backup for Witten and a potential flex player some weeks when our WRs are not up to snuff. McNabb has shown a fondness for Smith when they have been on the field...an unfortunate rarity in the last few years. Strong consideration was also being given to several players drafted just ahead (Williams, Johnson, SD) or behind (Rice, Garcia) these selections of ours.
===================================================================================