|
|

FanEx Analysis
Draft
Final Analysis Rules
| Transactions
Draft Rounds - See below
for analysis
1
| 2
| 3
| 4
| 5
| 6
| 7
| 8
| 9
| 10 |
11
| 12
| 13
| 14
| 15
| 16
| 17
| 18
| 19 |
20
Final
Analysis
| |
Tony
Holm
QB: Young
Rodgers Jackson RB:
Grant Parker McFadden JJones Fargas
WR:
RMoss Holmes Cotchery Berrian VJackson Gage TE:
Lee Miller
PK:
KBrown Scobee
DT: Jets Bills |
Overall
strategy: Let the draft come to me, be light on my feet
and be ready to make adjustments on the fly. Expect a RB
heavy draft so make sure I get some but also don't forget
about WR as the top guys look pretty thin this year.
Back up all positions in this format and have a good draft!
Most
likely starting roster most weeks: QB
Vince Young, TEN, RB Ryan Grant, GB, RB Willie Parker, PIT,
WR Randy Moss, NE, WR
Santonio Holmes, PIT, R/W Darren McFadden, OAK, TE Donald Lee,
GB, PK Kris Brown, HOU, TD Buffalo Bills
Strongest
position overall: I
think I have good balance throughout but I lean toward my WRs.
A lot of #1 guys and those that aren't are explosive #2's in
their system.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): TE. I
waited till the 14th and 16th round but I'm happy with my pair
of Donald Lee and Zach Miller. Both could have a fine
year from the position but it's definitely my weakest spot.
Your
Best move or pick of the draft: I think my
best move was waiting on QB. I was the last team to
draft one and many teams already had backups. I still
ended up with a big upside trio in Vince Young, Aaron Rodgers
and Tavares Jackson, two of the three in big time offenses.
Considering I didn't draft Young until the 9th round I think
that was my best move of the draft.
Your
Worst pick or move of the draft: There are two
things I'd reconsider. I'm a little worried about RB
Willie Parker as my 3rd round pick. I think he'll be
fine but 'thinking he'll be fine' as a 3rd round pick scares
me some. I also wish I took the Packers D when I had a
chance in the 18th round then selected a K and D with my 19th
and 20th round selections. I like the Bills D unit this
year and both the Bills and Jets have weak schedules this year
but still .. it's the Bills and the Jets. Yikes!
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? For
me, I'd select Team Matt Pitzer this year as the
team I like. Nice depth at QB with an upside pick in
Warner. I like his scat backs in this format, capable of
putting up some points but not a group you'd want in a start
'em weekly contest since you'd never know who was going to be
the point producer of the week. I really like the WRs
and I think that alone is tough to do this year with the
position scarcity of top wideouts. All the way down to
Owen Daniels, Ben Watson and the Colts D (a unit I was hoping
to slip through) .. I'd say Team Pitzer did a nice job in this
draft.
=================================================================================== |
| |
Ian
Allan
QB: Cutler
Garrard RB: SJackson Forte
KSmith Bradshaw Thomas
WR: AJohnson SSmith Welker CJohnson BrJohnson Wilford TE:
Davis Miller Olsen
PK:
Kaeding DT:
Seahawks Cardinals |
|
Overall
strategy: A lot of guys in this league overvalue running
backs. So I figured I’d stay out of that rat race and instead
get a lot of good pass catchers. I think it’s the smarter way
to go. They give a point per reception in this league, so
pass-catching is huge. You have the option to start four wide
receivers and only two running backs. And wide receivers are far
less likely to get hurt than running backs. I drafted only one
running back in the first four rounds last year and won this
league; so I figured I’d go that route again.
Most likely starting roster most weeks: QB Jay Cutler, RB
Steven Jackson, RB Matt Forte, WR Andre Johnson, WR Wes Welker,
WR Steve Smith, WR Calvin Johnson, TE Vernon Davis, K Nate
Kaeding, DT Seattle.
Strongest position overall: I believe I have four of the
top 15 wide receivers, plus the strongest combination of No. 5-6
receivers in Bryant Johnson and Ernest Wilford. I’m planning
on using four wide receivers most weeks, so I spent a lot of
resources on this position.
Weakest position overall (excluding D/ST and K): While
others were scrambling for running backs, I focused on
receivers, so I’m counting on unproven rookies to fill the No.
2 running back role – Matt Forte and Kevin Smith. I also
should be below-average on defense and at kicker (where I’ve
got maybe the best one but am not carrying a second kicker,
which should cost me about 25 points).
Your Best move or pick of the draft: I traded first- and
second-round picks to obtain Steven Jackson, who was the No. 2
running back on my board. That gave me an anchor at that
position, allowing me to concentrate on wide receivers with my
next three picks.
Your Worst pick or move of the draft: Everything fell
together nicely in this draft, so I don’t have any big
regrets. I would have liked for RB Thomas Jones to make it to
5.02; I traded into that spot thinking he would be there. But
we’ll be OK. Maybe I moved a round or two too early at tight
end with Vernon Davis at 11.08, but there wasn’t a different
player there I was dying to get. If Nate Kaeding gets hurt or
has a crappy year, I’ll regret carrying only one kicker.
If you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? A
third of the way through the draft, I really liked what John Georgopoulos
was doing, but then he selected a bunch of guys I don’t
like.
When I score out all of the teams using my stat projections, the
top 3 teams belong to Tony Holm, TC Cannon and Matt
Pitzer - in that order.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Greg
Kellogg
QB: Romo
Leinart ASmith RB:
Portis RBrown
Henry FJones Norwood
WR:
Marshal Evans Driver DCarter Meachem Ginn
TE:
Scheffler McMichael
PK:
Hanson Kasey
DT: Browns Lions |
|
Overall strategy:
No real strategy so to speak. I had a desire to have a
certain number of players at each position (5 RBs, 6 WRs and 3
QBs) with as many #1 or #2s as possible and as few risks as
possible.
Most likely starting
roster most weeks: That depends on health.
If all my players are as healthy as I think they will be then
it would be Romo, Portis, Brown, Henry, Marshall, Evans,
Driver, Scheffler, Hanson and the Browns.
Strongest position overall: Tossup
between RB and QB.
Weakest position overall
(excluding D/ST and K): WR - I count TE with the
kickers and defense.
Your Best move or pick of the
draft: Could be Henry in the 5th or one of my
secondary QBs.
Your Worst pick or move of the
draft: I took a chance by drafting players coming
off of injuries (Brown, Henry, Marshall, Scheffler).
That could backfire but it allowed me to get talented players
later than I normally would have.
If you had to, with whom would
you switch rosters and why? For the first time in the
FAD I don't think I would trade. If I had to, maybe Matt
Pitzer's squad but I would need Warner to win the QB
job before I would want to. Or Tony Holm's
squad which seems to be pretty balanced across all positions.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Duane
Cahill
QB: Brady
Russell RB:
LJohnson Graham Mendenhall McAllister CBrown RWilliams
WR:
Boldin Bowe Jennings Bruce Stallworth RWilliams TE:
DeClark Lewis
PK: Reed Longwell
DT: Raiders |
|
Overall
strategy: It
was paramount for me in a no-transactions league to have a
backup at every position. Make my last six picks TE, TE,
PK, PK, DT, DT, in that order. The reasons for taking the
DTs last are that you're sure they're going to make the team.
John Kasay might get cut. The Raiders defense won't.
Most
likely starting roster week in and week out: QB
- Tom Brady, RB - Larry Johnson, Earnest Graham, Deuce
McAllister, WR - Anquan Boldin, Dwayne Bowe, Greg Jennings, TE -
Marcedes Lewis, PK - Jeff Reed
DT - Oakland
Strongest
position overall: Running
back. I'm six deep, and every player is at worst part of a
tandem. No third-down backs or "cross-your-fingers
for an injury" guys for me.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
TE. By design. When you draft them as late as I do,
you cross your fingers and hope one that falls to you produces.
Best
move or pick of the draft:
Securing Tom Brady in the 2nd round allowed me to put off
selecting a backup QB until very late in the draft. This
allowed me two things: I was able to continue to draft RBs
and WRs while other teams took backup QBs and starting TEs.
My opinion is that I added a lot of depth at both positions due
to this one move. I was also able to scratch my plan to
take three QBs. I used the extra roster spot on a sixth RB
- Ricky Williams - that I think will pay off in a big way.
Worst
pick or move of the draft:
In retrospect, I'm not that enamored with Anquan Boldin.
There was a glitch in the draft and I tried to get Larry
Fitzgerald. I found out he'd been selected off the clock,
and Boldin was the first name that came to mind.
If you
had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
John Hanson. Oh, he's not in this? Sorry.
Force of habit. TC's starting unit is outstanding, but he
lacks depth. Shannon O'Leary's QB tandem is the best in
the league. Greg Kellogg's backfield would be the envy of
any fantasy team. Ian Allan's receivers are
downright scary. In fact, his team is solid, with very few
holes. Even his tight ends (I hate tight ends) are
outstanding. It wouldn't at all surprise me to see him go
back-to-back. Ian, let's do a Rosenbloom/Irsay
trade, whaddya say?
=================================================================================== |
| |
Matt
Pitzer
QB:
Hasselbeck Roethlisberger Warner RB:
Barber Bush BJackson Dunn Slaton
WR CJohnson Holt Curtis Clayton Curry TE:
Watson
PK:; Dawson
Tynes DT:
Colts Titans |
|
Overall
strategy: I wanted at
least two reliable starting quarterbacks, running backs who also
catch passes and wide receivers who will get a ton of
receptions. That's a combo that can win in this league if you
make the right picks.
Most
likely starting roster most weeks: Roethlisberger,
Marion Barber, Reggie Bush, Torry
Holt
,
Chad
Johnson, Kevin Curtis, Ahman Green, Owen Daniels, Indy D, Phil
Dawson.
Strongest
position overall: Have
to say quarterback. Both Roethlisberger and Matt Hasselbeck
should be very viable starters. I have two of them that I can
play off each other to get the most points. And then as my third
guy, I grabbed Kurt Warner. Maybe he doesn't play, but if he
does, he proved in 2007 that he still is pretty good.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): Tight
end. Owen Daniels and Ben Watson are both very uninspiring.
Watson caught a bunch of TDs in a short stretch last year, then
disappeared. I suppose I could be OK if he somehow becomes more
effective for a full season.
Your
Best move or pick of the draft:
I liked getting Holt and Johnson with back-to-back picks late in
the third and early in the fourth rounds. I know Holt is getting
old, but he'll be OK. And if Johnson is in the right frame of
mind, getting him in the fourth round could be a steal. I saw
them as the final two elite WRs at that point in the draft and I
loved getting both of them.
Your
Worst pick or move of the draft:
Taking Mark Clayton in the ninth round and Ronald Curry in the
14th. Hopefully, they will not matter much. But let's be honest:
Clayton will not be that great and Curry is a risk. My theory on
Curry is that Javon Walker will stink again and the Raiders have
no one else to throw to. But Curry already is hurt and what if
JaMarcus Russell is no good? That might almost be a wasted pick.
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? I'll
take Ian Allan's team because it has considerable
upside. I love having WRs such as Steve Smith, Andre Johnson and
Wes Welker. That's a ton of catches - if Johnson is healthy. The
running backs are risky as he is counting on Kevin Smith to be
one of his regular guys after Steven Jackson. But I also like
David Garrard in the ninth round. If he picks up where he left
off last year, that will be a great pick.
===================================================================================
|
|
|
Chris
Dolfi | Tom Walls
QB: Anderson
Quinn Grossman RB: Lynch Jones-Drew
Jacobs MBush FJackson KoSmith
WR: Housh Coles Hackett RWilliams TE:
Winslow Heap
PK: Suisham Elam
DT: Giants: |
|
Overall strategy:
Build from the backfield, get at least 3 good solid RBs in the
first 5 rounds. Take WRs and QBs as value dictates. Take 2
mediocre kickers late and they'll do just as well as anyone
else's 'stud'. Take only one top flight defense and use
the 'backup' pick for defense at WR or RB instead. (In
particular, this final strategy we have been employing in the
FAD for several years with positive results.)
Most likely starting roster most weeks:
QB - Derek Anderson (Cle), RB - Marshawn Lynch (Buf), Brandon
Jacobs (NYG), Maurice Jones-Drew (Jax), WR - T J Houshmandzedeh
(Cin), Santana Moss (Was), WR - Laverne's Coles (NYJ) TE -
Kellen Winslow (Cle), K - Shaun Suisham (Was), DT - Giants (NYG)
Strongest position overall: Running Back - we spent
3 of our first four picks overall on RB. There obviously is some
post-draft concern about Marshawn Lynch due to his recent legal
troubles (just a week or two after we drafted him), but we also
drafted his likely replacement, Fred Jackson, if he spends time
suspended or in jail. It's a sad reality of today's NFL - but a
lesson learned for fantasy. If you spend a top 3-round pick on a
player, be prepared to get his handcuff; not just for injuries,
but in case your player ends up *IN* handcuffs. MJD is solid,
and we expect Jacobs to find the end zone more often than his
poor showing last year. Not to mention a solid backup like
Michael Bush (who we expect to touch the ball at least a few
times every game) and backup with up-side like KC's Kolby Smith.
Weakest position overall (excluding D/ST and K): We are
obviously thin at QB, with little to no depth as far as weekly
starters except Derek Anderson. Rex Grossman is our bye week
backup, and he is no prize. We don't expect him to start for us
more than once or twice this season, tops. However, that doesn't
mean we're entirely unhappy with our QB picks. We have
full faith in the Browns offense this year, much like we did in
the Pats offense when we 'reached' by taking Tom Brady last
year. Between Anderson and Quinn, we feel strongly that whoever
the Browns QB is (for whatever reason) will do just fine for us,
putting up top 7 numbers.
Your Best move or pick of the draft: It was tempting to
say WRs Coles or Moss here, based on where we got them
(undervalued by many in our opinion), but we really think this
will be our second year in a row with a great pick at QB, Derek
Anderson. Perhaps we could have risked letting him slide another
round, but we liked him so much this year he was worth trading
up a few spots to make sure we grabbed him. We are big, big
believers in what the Browns will do with talent like Braylon
Edwards, Kellen Winslow, Donte` Stallworth and Jamal Lewis on
the field with our QB. While the 2008 Browns won't reach the
scoring prowess of the 2007 Patriots, they are cut from the same
mold and we fully expect Anderson and Winslow to figure into our
mix every game this year.
Your Worst pick or move of the draft: Hindsight is
always 20/20... So we gotta say Marshawn Lynch. A scary legal
situation for him crops up just a week or two after we draft
him; NEVER a good thing for your #1 pick in a draft. He will
undoubtedly pay some price for his part in the hit and run in
Buffalo, and we can only hope that it's minor. Thankfully,
we had the opportunity to draft his backup (Fred Jackson) even
before the news about Lynch hit, which should lessen the sting
at least a little bit.
If you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Of
course everyone always thinks their team is good - otherwise
they wouldn't have drafted them. But if you are honest
with yourself, you can almost always come up with someone who's
team you envy, even if just a little. This year was harder
than most for us to pick who we'd swap teams with... we really
think we had one of our best drafts ever this season. Since we
liked the job we did this draft, and since Shannon O'Leary
drafted such a similar team to ours, he is the only one
with whom we'd consider a swap. Very much like our own team, he
built a solid RB corps with three starting studs and three
quality backups. While we might not like either of his QBs
as much as our Anderson, together they will be just as
productive most weeks. Like us, he drafted one solid Defense,
two solid TEs, and his two kickers are actually a notch above
ours. Heck, he even mirrors us at the WR position with one stud
WR and then a cast of 5 others that make up for their lack of
'sure things' through quality in numbers. Nice team
Shannon, and a great draft strategy in our opinion. ;)
===================================================================================
|
|
|
Shannon
O'Leary
QB: Bulger
Delhomme RB:
Gore Lewis RJohnson Bell Foster Pittman
WR:
Fitzgerald White Walker Porter Bradley Booker TE:
Gonzalez ASmith
PK: Crosby
Rackers
DT: Bears Steelers |
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Jim
Butler
QB:
Brees Schaub Rivers RB:
McGahee White Duckett Buckhalter
WR: Galloway Sweed DJackson Glenn Henderson TE:
Gates Cooley Bennett
PK: Graham DT: Jaguars
Bengals: Eagles: |
|
Overall
strategy:
My overall strategy was to get at least one consistent performer
at each of the skill positions then back that one up with a
cluster of “streaky” players.
Most
likely starting roster most weeks: QB:
Drew Brees, RB: LenDale White, RB: Willis McGahee, RB: T.J.
Duckett, WR: Joey Galloway, WR: Devery Henderson, WR: Terry
Glenn, TE: Antonio Gates, TE: Chris Cooley
Strongest position overall: I
would say that my strongest position is QB, especially if Rivers
performs at his 2006 level.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
My weakest position is probably WR. Very risky selections there.
Your
Best move or pick of the draft:
Getting Philip Rivers in Round 10.
Your
Worst pick or move of the draft:
Probably trading away Stephen Jackson for Willis McGahee.
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
One thing about a league filled with owners of this caliber,
there won’t be any glaringly poor drafts. If I had to pick a
team to switch with it would be Dolfi/Walls. They
have a probably have the strongest RB corps and that usually
leads to strong scoring week in and week out.=================================================================================== |
|
|
John
Georgopoulos
QB: EManning
Edwards RB:
Westbrook TJones DWilliams Betts CWilliams Bennett
Washington
WR: Wayne
Colston Ward Branch DJackson Toomer TE:
Crumpler King
PK: Stover Feeley
DT: Ravens |
Overall
strategy: To be honest, I had little to no strategy for this
draft. I was asked to step in with little notice... a fact
evident that I did not realize the scoring rules until the 20th
round of the draft. But in general-- grab the most statistically
valuable position in spades early, then work the progression to
the least valuable. I normally hate drafting this early for
several reasons-- lack of camp for rookies, pending roster
moves, player legal woes-- as well as the fact that my bible of
drafting, the Sports Grumblings trend analysis and projections,
isn't normally
completed until the first or second week of June.
Most likely starting roster most weeks: QB: E.
Manning; RB: Westbrook, T.Jones; WR: Wayne, Colston, Ward; TE:
Crumpler; Flex: Any one of those WR2 types; K: Stover; DT:
Ravens.
Strongest position overall: Without a doubt, WR. I
managed to snag three WR1 in Colston, Wayne and Ward, and the
remainder of the corps are comprised of WR2 like D. Bennett, D.
Branch, A. Toomer and DJax.
Weakest position overall (excluding D/ST and K): RB.
While Westbrook and Jones will be a very good overall tandem, I
failed to get any serious backups (DeAngelo Williams is a high
risk/reward) and missed the obvious handcuff (Buckhalter).
Your Best move or pick of the draft: On a value basis, it
is probably Toomer for an 18th-round pick.
Your Worst pick or move of the draft: Agreeing to
the Draft without knowing the rules. I hate to admit it, but I
didn't know this was a 'best-ball' league. That changes the
dynamic and I would have made some different choices; at the
very least, I would have properly backed up my DT.
If you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
Tony Holm's squad would be unbeatable with an
NFL-proven QB;
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Jerome
Hickerson
QB: Palmer
Campbell Pennington RB:
Addai Maroney Taylor CJohnson Rice Rhodes
WR: Edwards
Harrison Gonzales RBrown Rice TE:
Shockey Eric Johnson
PK:
JBrown Bironas
DT: Cowboys Vikings |
| Overall
strategy:
I always draft for value,
looking for the best value on the board. Within that overarching
strategy, I usually take at least two RBs
within the first three rounds. Drafting against the guys in FAD,
you are almost forced to overemphasize RBs
early in the draft. It is usually my intention to wait until the
5th or 6th round for a QB, and to take my
first TE in the 7th round. But I go with the flow of
the draft – if a QB or a TE pops to the top of my value list,
I’ll grab him earlier. In this draft, Carson Palmer surfaced
at the top of my list late in the 4th round. Overall,
in a word, my primary strategy is to draft for value, concerns
about filling positions can be addressed after the first 8 or 9
rounds.
Most likely starting roster
most weeks: QB
Carson Palmer, RB Joseph Addai, RB
Laurence Maroney, WR Braylon
Edwards, WR Marvin Harrison, WR Reggie Brown, TE Jeremy Shockey,
Flex Fred Taylor, PK Josh Brown, DT Dallas Cowboys
Strongest position overall: I
really don’t see a significant strong roster position on this
franchise, but neither do I see any glaring weaknesses. Forced
to choose, I’d say that RB is slightly the stronger position,
with two good backs in good situations, an adequate but aging 3rd
back, two rookies with talent in good situations, and a handcuff
for my #1 back.
Weakest position overall
(excluding D/ST and K): Once
again, I don’t see any real weakness, but the lack of depth at
TE is a concern that could cost some points.
Your Best move or pick of the
draft: I liked the
Marvin Harrison pick in the 5th round. I think he
will outperform his draft position. The Reggie Brown pick late
in the 8th round also strikes me as a selection that
could outperform.
Your Worst pick or move of the
draft: I wish I
could have waited later to take Anthony Gonzalez. But I felt
that I needed him to protect my interest in Marvin Harrison. I
felt exposed with Harrison and wanted to cover myself if
something doesn’t work out.
If you had
to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Forced
to choose, I’d have to choose Terry Cannon’s
franchise. The Manning/Peterson/Owens 1-2-3 punch sure seems to
outweigh any weaknesses. He had an interesting strategy of
taking three kickers, which I find unusual, but the 1-2-3 punch
plus Burress and Chambers should
make this franchise a contender.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
TC
Cannon
QB: Manning
Garcia Sorgi RB:
Peterson Stewart Benson Young Watson
WR:
Owens Burress Chambers Engram Hardy TE:
Clark Utecht
PK:
Folk Gostkowski Gould
DT: Chargers Packers |
|
Overall
strategy: I targeted strong starters, with less emphasis
on claiming expensive rushers. However, things did not work out
to allow me to do anything significant with RBs. Soo. The
modified strategy was STRONG starters and reasonable rushers.
Most likely
starting roster most weeks: QB:
Manning, RB: Peterson, RB Young, WR: Owens, Burress, Hardy,
Chambers, TE: Dallas Clark, PK: Folk, DT: Chargers
Strongest
position overall: Balance. Yet, Manning makes
passer my most solid position.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): TE Dallas Clark
is popular, but he is seldom a weekly star.
Your Best
move or pick of the draft: Trading up and gaining an
extra second round pick. Adding Manning plus Owens was worth the
cost.
Your Worst
pick or move of the draft: Missing out on WR Curtis
(Pitzer 7.07) and DT Cowboys (Henderson 14.10) bothered me. I
could have easily had both. My least favorite selection was 9.02
RB Benson. It was a need pick, based on available RB talent.
(ATF: Benson's newest legal woes and Young moving way up in the
Bronco's depth chart balanced out.)
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
If I must, please give me the semi popular Rito |
Nazarek roster. They and I selected back-to-back almost the
entire draft, and we seemed to have similar targets. Chris and
Mike have strong RBs, and a FF balance that is impressive.
McNabb I'm not so sure of, but if these sharp owners like him,
who am I to strongly disagree.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Chris
Rito | Mike Nazarek
QB: McNabb
Kitna Coyle RB: Tomlinson James Turner
CTaylor
WR: RWilliams Mason Burleson Gaffney Walter Patten TE:
Witten LJSmith
PK: Akers Janikowski
DT: Patriots Buccaneers |
| Overall
strategy: We planned to
secure depth at RB with two RBs in the top three picks, and
three in the top five selections. generally, we feel that it is
easier to get good scoring from average WRs in a "best
ball" scoring system, so sacrificing some "star
power" at WR could allow us to be competitive at WR while
loading up the other positions. Drafting from the #1 hole (and
therefore at the end of the even rounds), we knew that sometimes
we would have to make a reach selection to start a run, instead
of having to react at the end of it.
Most likely starting roster
most weeks: QB McNabb, RB
Tomlinson - James - Turner, WR Roy Williams - Mason -
Burleson/Walter, TE Witten, K Akers, D New England Patriots
Strongest position overall:
Its hard not to have a strong RB crew when you take three RBs
with your first three picks, especially when one of them is LT.
Sammy Morris and Chester Taylor also provide nice depth and will
occasionally score and start for us. We feel very safe at RB. We
also feel confident that we have backups at TE and D which are
stronger than many teams' starter, which will assure that we get
good scoring from those positions relative to our opposition.
Weakest position overall
(excluding D/ST and K):
We have a great number of #2 and #3 fantasy WRs and Roy Williams
is a weak #1; however, Mason was a nice mid-round find in a PPR
league as a reception machine and consistent point producer.
Obviously WR is our potential bugaboo as we have few if any
guaranteed starters every week. However, the rules of this game
do not require us to select our starters, so we don't have to
guess when our erratic scorers will produce. This is an
important lesson for all drafters - know your scoring system and
draft accordingly.
Your Best move or pick of the
draft: At this point, it
would have to be taking TE Witten when we did and the fact that
we gambled and still got QB McNabb with the next pick. Witten in
a PPR league should be at or near the top TE point producer
level, and we waited for a QB until the end of round 6 and still
got a guy that could be among the league leaders at his
position. Time will tell on Michael Turner, which is likely the
move that will make or break this team - if he breaks out as
many predict, we will be solid. If not...we would likely would
have been better served by taking Colston/Edwards/Fitzgerald
with that pick.
Your Worst pick or move of the
draft: Hard to say
without the benefit of hindsight....maybe the riskiest picks
(aside from passing on a stud WR as mentioned above) were WR
Burleson and WR Gaffney in the middle rounds. Each are in a mix
of players at their position and each could be huge....or a
wasted pick. We have reasons to like these two guys, but maybe
they could have been had later and maybe they will each stink. A
risk on a boom-or-bust pick with higher upside might have been
better - like maybe Bryant Johnson, James Hardy or Donte
Stallworth. We also waited a round too long for some of those
sleepers at WR - an unfortunate by-product of our draft position
since it is hard to predict 22 intervening picks.
If you had to, with whom would
you switch rosters and why?
In a league of this caliber, every team has a weak spot - no one
can be loaded with 11 other smart drafters. Hickerson and Cahill
have notable squads with their starters, but not comfortable
depth if something bad happens. That leaves us with either TC or
Ian Allen as having the most dangerous squads, but each have to
rely on some unexpected or unpredictable performance at the
crucial RB position. TC's star power with Manning, Peterson,
Burress and T.O. is striking and has good
"peripherals" at TE-K-D; Ian can run four ridiculous
WRs out there every week, no matter what and has Steven Jackson
as well. We give the nod to TC Cannon since we
repeatedly said "Curse that TC!!" during this draft as
he took our preferred players right in front of us. LOL
=================================================================================== |
|
|
|