|
|

FanEx Analysis
Draft
Final Analysis Rules
| Transactions
Draft Rounds - See below
for analysis
1
| 2
| 3
| 4
| 5
| 6
| 7
| 8
| 9
| 10 |
11
| 12
| 13
| 14
| 15
| 16
| 17
| 18
| 19 |
20
Final
Analysis
| |
Tony
Holm
QB: McNabb
Orton Campbell RB: CJohnson
KSmith Thomas McGahee Sproles
WR: CJohnson Bryant
Berrian Hixon Maclin Walker
TE: Witten Boss
PK: Crosby Brown
DT: Redskins
49ers |
Overall
strategy: Dominate!
I've been in a few drafts already so have a fairly good feel
for how the chips
are falling this year. I really like being in the
middle in a draft and pick #7 is a good spot for me.
Being in the middle of the draft I play a "let the
draft come to me" strategy whereas if I had a #1, #2 or
#11 or #12
selection I would be a little more aggressive
with my selections, drafting whomever I wanted regardless of
ADP. My current set FAD philosophy is to draft 3 QBs
and try to get them fairly quickly as they will all dry up
around the 11th round. Load up on 5 RBs, 6 WRs due to
the fact we have to start 3 of them, then a TE, K and D with
backups at all positions to get the big score opportunities.
When TC comes knocking for a trade
accept it
and that completes my FAD strategy. I'm very happy
with this draft and the way it shook out for me.
Strongest
position overall: I
really like my balance throughout but I'd say QB and RB lead
the way for me. Witten and Boss at TE don't stink
either.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): I'd
say WR because I bounced around cherry picking other
positions at the cost of loading up at WR. I was
planning on throwing quantity at the position with upside
guys late which I did. My WR group is anchored with a
good one, Calvin Johnson, and the rest are all solid
but hopefully rookie Jeremy Maclin pans out to be a Reggie
Bush type player and Mike Walker shows up in
the box score from time to time. We'll see.
Your
best move or pick of the draft: I
really like Saints RB Pierre Thomas at 5.07 and Chargers
RB
Darren Sproles at 9.07. Those guys both could be
monsters in this format. I also liked when I grabbed
my QBs, McNabb in the 7th, Orton in the 10th and Jason
Campbell in the 11th seemed to be just the right time
to
grab them without paying for them.
Your proudest moment: I
did get an email compliment from another owner in this draft
that really liked what
I was doing. That was a nice compliment to receive.
When others notice what you're doing and like it, there's
definitely a sense of pride there. I actually do
invest a lot in this draft as it is the draft I look forward
to most each year.
The worst
pick or move of the draft:
In the FAD I just don't believe in backing up players and
while there were a couple picks that I thought were a
little curious, like Todd Heap or Byron Leftwich, the
Dallas RB grouping on Team Davis I think will end up
biting him in this format. Naturally, Davis will win
the whole thing
now and plaster my quote all over his site for years
of visitors to see. Oh joy!
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Everyone
has holes but I think Team
Pitzer or Team Allan would be my first choice. For
Team Pitzer I really like the QBs and RBs and he has a
nice 1-2 punch at WR with Reggie Wayne and Roy Williams.
I also like his TEs and Ds. I think where his team runs
into trouble is with his other 4 WRs as it's a long season
to be asking for consistent contributions from at least 2 of
those guys every week which he'll need to win this.
Just an opinion of course! I think Team Allan has
drafted another gem that should be good for 2nd place this
year. ;-) I'd take my chances with
Team Ian Allan if I had to swap teams
with honorable mention to (in no particular order) Team
Pitzer of
course, Team Cahill and Team Dolfi/Walls. Great
drafting with ya'll, enjoy the season!
=================================================================================== |
| |
Ian
Allan
QB:
Roethlisberger Garrard Leftwich RB: Bush
White Benson Rice Washington Bradshaw
WR: SSmith Welker Gonzalez Ochocinco Muhammad
TE: Celek Miller PK:
Reed Kasay DT:
Patriots Dolphins |
|
Overall strategy:
I don’t go into these things with any grand ideas. I’m
just trying to collect some good
players. If I was more serious
about it, I suppose, I would spend more time trying to negotiate
trades. I should really make an effort to trade down every time
I’m on the clock – see if I can collect extra picks in the
middle rounds. But instead, I think 18 of my 20 picks were
pre-loaded, with the computer selecting my highest-
ranking
player. In each of the past two years, I’ve won this
competition. Both of those teams had four good
wide receivers,
so I made sure I put together a nice group at that position. And
I tried to key on reliable,
durable guys. It’s a long season
and there are no roster moves allowed, so I wanted guys I could
count on playing 16 games.
Strongest position: You start three wide receivers in
this league. It’s also a PPR league, and there’s also a
“flex” position, which can be a wide receiver. So I wanted a
nice quartet of very reliable wide receivers. I
wound up picking
four of the top 15 on my board.
Weakest position: I was the last to select a quarterback
and the last to select a running back. (I was also
one of the
last at kicker, tight end and defense). At running back, we’ve
got a deep group of guys and players who’ll catch a lot of
passes, so I think we’ll be OK there. I don’t think I will
outscore many at quarterback,
where I’ve got a pretty ordinary
trifecta of Roethlisberger, Garrard and Leftwich.
Best move: If Ray Rice winds up being Baltimore’s
starting tailback and putting up about 1,600 yards and 10 TDs,
he’ll be my best pick. But I didn’t really have any
“steals” in this draft. I didn’t select any players who
went way later than expected. I was looking at a mock draft that
was done a few weeks ago by the Lindy’s magazine. In it, every
single player on my team was selected later (in that draft) than
where I selected them.
Proudest moment: In the 12th round, I felt there was only
one good running back left on the board – Ahmad Bradshaw, whom
I wanted as a depth guy. I made a series of trade offers in that
round. I think I contacted four guys. I finally got Matt Pitzer
to agree to deal pick 12.10. I grabbed Bradshaw there, and it
wound up that TC Cannon had Bradshaw queued up for pick 12.11.
Worst pick of the draft: I was shocked that two guys
selected only one defense. If you run the numbers on double
defenses, with volatile scoring at that position, that seems to
equal punting 30-45 points. And two
others went with just one
kicker. I can see doing one kicker if it’s a really good one
(I did it myself with Nate Kaeding last year), but Harmon’s
doing it with Matt Prater. I’m not sure Prater is going to
last 16 games with Denver. Most surprising pick of the first
three rounds: LaDainian Tomlinson at No. 4 overall; I was
wondering
if any team would even be willing to use a second-round pick on
him.
Best team: I have exact stat projections for each player,
but I never quite know how to score this particular contest,
with the best-ball dimension, 10-man starting and no waiver
moves. Every team selected at least 2 QBs, 1 Defense, 1 kicker
and 12 players eligible for the flex (RB-WR-TE). If we throw out
the remaining four players off each roster and total up the
points for just those 16 guys, the top teams (according to my
numbers) belong to Chris Rito, Tony Holm and Matt
Pitzer. As luck would have it, each of those guys selected 3 QB,
2 TE, 2 PK, 2 D and 11 RB-WR. If we total up all 20 guys for
each of those three, it works out to Holm (3458 points), Rito
(3435) and Pitzer (3351). So I’ll go with Holm’s team.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Greg
Kellogg
QB: Brady
DelHomme RB:
Tomlinson Wells DBrown Fargas Bush
WR: Owens VJackson Mason SSmith Burleson Britt
TE: Clark Ingram
PK: Lindell
Hanson DT:
Jets Bills |
|
Overall
strategy: I decided
to attempt to get the best possible starting lineup I could and
fill in from around there.
Strongest
position overall:
I don't believe I have a strong position. My strategy
wasn't designed to load
up on one position over the others.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
Again, I don't believe I have a weak position. I have a
top player in each of the four positions and good depth around
them.
Your
best move or pick of the draft:
If Donald Brown gets the starting job, as I suspect he will,
getting him
in the ninth round will be my best pick of the
draft. If not, I like Nate Burleson in the 11th.
Your proudest moment: Of the draft? I guess I am
proudest of not holding anyone up with my picks or my analysis.
Not really sure what you are after here Terry.
The worst pick or move of the draft: I hate to second guess Ian Allan
who has won this thing twice in a row but I feel his
taking Anthony Gonzalez when both Anquan Boldin and
Brandon Marshall were still on the board was as big a
mistake as anyone has made in the draft this year.
If you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
Chris Rito and Mike Nazarek - they
have a very balanced team
with a very strong threesome at wideout.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Duane
Cahill
QB:
Manning Flacco RB:
SJackson Jacobs LJohnson Mendenhall James
WR: Royal Ward
Crabtree Burress Henry Engram Robiskie
TE: Gonzalez Keller
PK: Gostkowski
Longwell DT:
Texans Cardinals |
|
Overall strategy:
For the first 10-12 rounds, let the draft come to me.
Take the best players that fell to me. For the final few
rounds, get two good kickers, two mid-round defenses and take
a few chances.
Strongest
position overall: Running
Back. Steven Jackson, Brandon Jacobs, Larry Johnson and
Rashard Mendenhall. If Edge winds up on a roster, this
could be the best group in the FAD this year. Otherwise,
I feel good about my TEs and Ks.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): Most likely
WR. I didn't draft my first until the sixth
round and Eddie Royal is my WR1. I'm hoping to overcome
my lack of quality with some fortuitous quantity.
Your
best move or pick of the draft:
I liked getting Hines Ward two rounds after Santonio Holmes
was drafted. I think Ward easily out-points him.
Your proudest moment: Having the
self-discipline to wait until the last round to take Edgerrin
James.
The worst
pick or move of the draft:
Sorry TC, but in years to come we may be calling this the
"Knowshon Moreno Award". Halfway through the third round
is way too early to grab a fifth rounder. While I have
no issue with the fact that Moreno is a rookie, he's playing
for a head coach who, as an offensive coordinator, never had a feature back. The Broncos are sitting with a
half-dozen possibilities on their current roster and I have a
hard time believing that Moreno cracks the 700 yard or 6 TD
mark.
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Sorry,
Ian. This year it's Tony Holm's league to
lose. I like his combination of quarterbacks, and his
running backs and wide receivers contain
many value picks. On at least three occasions, he
grabbed the guy I was going to take the pick for my turn.
=================================================================================== |
| |
Matt
Pitzer
QB:
Rivers Palmer Quinn RB: Jones-Drew Grant
Lewis Norwood Morris
WR: Wayne RWilliams
SMoss Curtis Heyward-Bay
TE: Olsen Davis PK:
Tynes Mare DT:
Packers Bucs |
|
Overall
strategy: Had to,
and wanted to, take a stud running back in the first round and
then load up on guys who will catch a lot of passes as well as
solidify my quarterback spots.
Strongest
position overall:
I have a lot of "could bes." It could be QB if
Carson Palmer is back to where he was a couple of seasons ago.
It could be RB if Ryan Grant comes on strong for
Green Bay
. It could be WR
if Roy Williams comes through. And it could
even be TE if Greg Olsen and Vernon Davis live up to a decent
percentage of their natural talent. In other words, I don't
really know.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
Whichever of those positions doesn't come through
will be the weak spot, without question. I'll say it most likely
will be RB. I love Maurice Jones-Drew (though
third overall is risky). Ryan Grant is OK but certainly no
game-changer as a No. 2 back. And then guys such
as Jamal Lewis, Sammy Morris and Jerious Norwood aren't exactly
setting my heart all aflutter.
Your
best move or pick of the draft:
Getting RB Williams near the end of the fourth round. If he
is a legit
No. 1 receiver, in an offense that loves to throw, that will be
a great pick. Of course, that is a good-sized if.
Your proudest moment: Taking Deion Branch at pick 13.11.
It's a late pick and probably will not matter much. But I sat
there for 10 minutes thinking about taking him at 13.03. I
eventually took Darrius Heyward-Bey with the first pick (which
is nothing to be proud of) and then Branch was still there
later, making me quite
happy. Or maybe I just completely misvalued Branch.
The worst
pick or move of the draft:
I
will call out Duane Cahill here because I don't think there is
any way that Steven Jackson is worth the sixth overall pick in a
draft. At one time, he might have gotten there on talent alone.
But that time is past after a couple of seasons wrecked by
injuries and a Rams team wrecked by horrible players. The
offensive line is only at the very beginning of a rebuilding
process and the rest of the offense is in shambles. Yes, they do
have a new coach who would love to establish a strong running
game. I
do not see much to suggest that
Jackson
will be able to do so.
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? It's
Greg Kellogg's team - although with another giant
'if.' And that is if LaDainian Tomlinson is healthy. He spent
that first-round pick on Tomlinson; if
it doesn't work out, his season could go down the tubes. But if
Tomlinson is golden again, a 1-2 combo with Chris Wells (whom I
think will be very good) could lead the way. Tom Brady is my No.
1 QB so I like him at the end of round 2. And regardless of what
you think about Terrell Owens, taking him in the third round is
a good value. He has enough other high-upside guys following
(the other Steve Smith, Donald Brown, etc.) that somebody will
come through and make him happy.
===================================================================================
|
|
|
Chris
Dolfi | Tom Walls
QB: Rodgers
Hill Pennington RB:
Peterson RBrown JJones Hightower Graham
WR: White Evans Avery Ginn Gage Bradley
TE: Fasano
Pettigrew PK:
Bironas Hartley
DT:
PHI |
|
Since Dolfi and Walls don't always agree on
everything, we're going to give you *BOTH* our takes on all the
answers to the FAD questionnaire. :)
Overall
strategy: Dolfi's
Take
- Does anyone *really* have a strategy other than "best
available"?!? I mean seriously, we looked at every position
individually, and made picks based on what value we could gain
at that specific point in the draft. Ok - maybe one slight
strategy is that we STILL believe in getting good RBs early, and
taking Ks and DEFs very late.
Walls'
Take
– There's no statute of limitations on sexiness, we all know
it. That's he we roll... We always like
to have good RBs, and that reflects our team’s make up. In the
past we had gone for more sure things at
WRs, but this year we took some more upside picks in the past,
betting on increased production, that seems
to be key to winning this particular draft (since we can't react
to sleepers with free agent pickups).
Strongest position
overall:
Dolfi's
Take
- We've already had some negative feedback on our QB picks -
but
I honestly think it's out strongest position in this draft. We
have a legit top 5 performer in Aaron Rodgers,
we back him up
with
Shaun Hill, who we simply can't see NOT winning the 49ers job,
especially considering he was the BEST
QB in the NFC West in the second half of the season. And we have
Pennington as our #3 QB... seriously, we are deep in QB talent.
Walls'
Take
– I think RB is our strongest position. This hinges on two
players, Hightower and Julius Jones. If Hightower can be on the
field for most of the Cards snaps, he could rack up some nice
yardage and receptions. Julius Jones is a curious case; I
believe he will be a very pleasant surprise. Like Hightower,
he
will likely not be his team’s short yardage back, but with
Hasselback back, a new zone blocking scheme and
a very favorable schedule against rushing defenses Jones could
sneak into the top 20 of all RBs. Earnest Graham is a nice
addition to round out our late round corps. Add Ronnie Brown,
and by the way Adrian Peterson (the first overall pick), and we
have a very nice pack of RBs.
Weakest position overall
(excluding D/ST and K):
Dolfi's
Take
- TE is obviously a position we are going
to need some luck at.
We missed the top 3-4 can't miss TEs, and then underestimated other team's desire
for TEs.
We end up with Fasano as our #1, and a crap-shoot at Pettigrew
as our #2. We waited slightly too long at TE and we paid the
price - time will tell if
that wait was the right decision...
Walls'
Take
– I agree with Dolf here. We waited, and paid by not getting
any of the second tier of TEs. It’s a trade off we can live
with though. We will see hat Pettigrew is for the Lions, a team
in need of another weapon besides Calvin Johnson. Fasano is
underrated, I believe, we got him a little lower than he should
have gone, but likely will have one of the weakest TE producing
teams.
Your best move or pick
of the draft:
Dolfi's
Take
- There are several picks that I *love* for where we got them...
the Eagles D at 15.01 and Tim Hightower at 8.12 stand out for
me... but I honestly LOVE our pick of Shaun Hill at 10.12 in
this draft. Tom and I both loved the upside on this guy, and he
could legitimately be a
top 12 QB in this scoring format. The
fact we got a guy like that so deep in this draft is something I
think has
a great chance of being our best move in the draft.
Walls'
Take
– Hmmm…. Well I like the Jones pick. For all the reasons I
listed above , we got real value there.
Your proudest moment:
Dolfi's
Take
- Honestly - is this a serious question? ;) How
"proud" can we be
about a draft that has yet to play itself out?!? Ok - I'll bite... My proudest moment was
waking out up out of a
14 hour Scotch coma on my living room
floor and still being able to make solid picks like Shaun Hill
at the bottom of the 10th.
Walls'
Take
– Using the term No Fat Chicks in my write up for our second
kicker...? I guess that would be it.
Or drafting Pennington whilst nude. One of those two.
The worst pick or move
of the
draft: Dolfi's
Take
- Another hard one for me. Most picks I clearly
understood the owner's motivation, even if I didn't agree with
it. I wasn't a fan of TC Cannon taking Jeremy Shockey at
12.11 (his lack of production and injury risk make me think even
being in the New Orleans offense won't help) - especially before
backing up his QB (even if it was Drew Brees). But I'll
give TC a pass on that one due to the lack of real talent at the
QB slot left on the board at the time. So my vote for
worse pick of the draft is Greg Kellogg's pick of the Giants WR
Steve Smith at 8.09. It's not that I don't think Smith
will be a decent WR, heck he may even end up starting over
either Nicks or Hixon. But right now he is the #3 WR
on
the Giants and he gets picked not only before the listed #1 and
#2 WRs, but even IF you liked him that much, why not get him 2-3
rounds later (when I am almost positive he would have still been
available)? I hope Greg
is right in thinking Smith will be the best WR on that team, but
even if that pans out, I still don't understand why the pick had
to be made in the 8th round.
Walls' Take
– I noticed other owners picking the worst overall (namely
other teams)…that’s not the question here, right? It is what
I think our worst move was. I agree with the whole TE thing. But
I will say I regret passing on McNabb in the 7th round. We
didn’t need a QB but getting McNabb there would have been a
great value pick. I am glad we got Avery there, but McNabb would
have been an awesome value…You’re welcome Mr. Holm.
If you had to, with whom
would you switch rosters and why?
Dolfi's
Take
- This was a super-hard question for me this year - usually
there is someone's team I am salivating over when I look at the league rosters, but not so
much this year. I like Tony Holm's team quite a bit, especially
the upside on the McNabb pick, but I think he's as thin as we
are at WR. Brian Hulett's team also gets an honorable mention
from me, I love his WR corps and think he's overall one of the
most solid teams in this draft. But since I'm forced to pick
someone I'd trade with, I'm going to give the nod to Matt
Pitzer's team. 3 QBs that will put up numbers at
some time or another this
season, a slightly thin RB corps - but one who's top end should keep him competitive, and a WR corps which is the
right mix of solid picks and risk/reward picks, combined with
solid
(if unexciting) picks at TE, K, and DEF/ST make me think
that Pitzer is a lock to finish in the top half, and with a
little luck will take home the crown.
Walls'
Take
– I was going to write Rito/Nazarek, but with the recent
surgeries to Westbrook and Addai, there
is enough of a question there for me to back off. I like Tony
Holm’s team quite a bit also, but I will say Matt
Pitzer. I love his WR corps, and I think his RBs are
deep enough to carry him through to a top 3 finish.
===================================================================================
|
|
|
Mike
Harmon
QB: Romo
Edwards Favre RB:
Slaton Ward
TJones Greene McCoy Coffee
WR: Moss
Housh Driver Holt Crayton RDavis
TE: Shiancoe
McMichael
PK:
Prater: DT: Chargers
Seahawks |
|
Overall strategy:
As this is one of the first drafts of the new year, the boards are still
shifting and trying to determine where players rank in this
collective. That makes for an interesting draft flow. So, while
you target certain players, it’s more of a tiered breakdown
approach followed by need.
Obviously,
the PPR setting changes the complexion of the draft. As such, I
rolled up top options at both RB and WR to pile up receptions.
The trio of Slaton, Ward and Jones has their value, not to
mention the A-list options of Moss and Houshmandzadeh. Brady is
back in full effect, and a healthy Seattle offense means more
big-time numbers from Houshmandzadeh. I also looked for value
later with veteran players at wideout. Holt and Driver aren’t
sexy, but they’re effective in this format.
Strongest
position overall: I’m
excited about the stable of running backs. I know I went heavy
on the rookie backs, but I believe each of them will play a big
role. Last week’s news of Westbrook’s surgery certainly
makes McCoy a value pick.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): The quarterback position is
potentially problematic. I believe that there’s a moderate
drop-off forthcoming from Romo in the post-TO world. I drafted
Edwards on the possible upside in joining with TO, but there’s
no guarantee there. And, Favre is just Favre.
Your Best move
or pick of the draft: I was happy to see Thomas Jones slide into the sixth
round. Jones’s contract situation is certainly something to
watch, but last year’s totals certainly suggest that there’s
plenty left in the tank. The selection of LeSean McCoy is
potentially huge.
Worst pick or
move of the draft: I was curious about the selection of Anthony Gonzalez when Marshall, Gates
and Boldin were still on the board, but I’ll go with my roll
of the dice at kicker. First, I didn’t grab a second for the
position, and Prater is a pretty sizable gamble. So, I’ll take
the hit.
If you had to,
with whom would you switch rosters and why? The
Rito-Nazarek squad is fearsome. Obviously, if
Westbrook comes back healthy and produces his normal output
alongside Warner and that dominant stable of receivers,
they’re rolling. Add to that two dominant defenses and strong
TE play and they’ve got the recipe to put up some wins.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Craig
Davis
QB:
Schaub Cassel Culpepper RB:
Forte Barber FJones Jackson Maroney Choice KJones
WR:
Bowe Edwards Holmes Austin Harvin BJones
TE: Carlson Scheffler
PK: Gould:
DT: Cowboys |
|
Overall
strategy:
With so much attention placed on WRs nowadays and drafting from
where I was, I figured I could land two very good RBs and then
make my move on some talented WRs. Nabbing Forte and Barber
allowed me to stick to my original plan, then I was able to grab
Bowe, Braylon and even Santonio Holmes to complete a very nice
RB/WR tandem.
Strongest
position overall:
RB --- Forte will have to repeat his 2008 performance in order
for my drafting strategy to have worked, but I see no reason
(with Cutler under center) why that can’t happen. Marion
Barber should have another solid year, even with Felix Jones
(who I also have) taking some of his carries this year. Laurence
Maroney and Fred Jackson will get some chances to win a starting
job, so I’m talented and deep at this position.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
Probably QB. I still like my QBs, but I waited till I had other
pieces in place before taking a QB. Schaub is injury prone and
we don’t know how well Cassel will do in a new system.
Your Best
move or pick of the draft:
Grabbing all three Dallas Cowboys RBs. The offensive line is
fantastic and the passing game is good enough to keep defenses
honest. One of those three (if not two of them) is going to have
a top 10 season (likely Barber). Just in case one or two of them
get hurt, I’m still going to have the other one who will shine
in this offense.
Worst pick or
move of the draft *any team*: I know this is a copout answer,
but I really don’t think it’s fair to say there was a
“worst pick” of the draft. It’s too early to tell many of
these players are going to perform, and as inconsistent as the
last few seasons have gone it’s nearly impossible to tell
whether or not anyone had a “bad” pick. Sorry.
If you had
to, with whom would you switch rosters and why?
It’s hard to argue with what Matt Pitzer did. One stud QB
followed by a guy who has the potential to be a stud again
(Carson Palmer) is a good start. Add to that his RB corps that
includes Maurice Jones-Drew and Ryan Grant, a player who I think
has all the capability in the world to rush for 1500 yards and
15 TDs this year and you have a great start. He then added
Reggie Wayne and Roy Williams to the mix, and if you think
Williams is going to be as bad as he was last year, think again.
In that offense, Williams stands to catch 90 balls for 1300
yards. Solid starting lineup, but little depth. If he suffers
through the injury bug he could be in trouble, but overall I
really like this team.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
John
Georgopoulos (With O'Leary)
QB: Cutler
EManning Sanchez RB:
D Williams Portis Lynch R Williams
WR: DJackson Breaston Walter Hester Bruce Randle El Washington
TE: Gates Scaife PK:
Akers Bryant DT:
Steelers Panthers
|
|
Overall
strategy: Coming on mid-stream, the strategy was to
try and find a series of WRs that could
produce just 3-4 good games a year, then hope for the best,
while then maximizing value at the PK and DEF positions in an
effort to max out weekly point potential. Risky, but I felt it
was the best shot at an “in the money” placement…
Strongest position overall: Running Back
Weakest position overall (excluding D/ST and K): Wide
Receiver
Your best
move or pick of the draft: Probably Ricky Williams in
the 12th. They may not be plentiful, but as
a big-play Flex in a best-ball league, Williams may make a
difference in 1-2 matchups this year.
If you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Would
probably go with Matt Pitzer’s team. Good QB
trio, solid RB rotation and really good WR corps. Might come
down to TE Vernon Davis
finally living up to the hype (or Greg Olsen getting to the next
level)
=================================================================================== |
|
|
|
|
TC
Cannon
QB:
Brees Russell RB: Turner Moreno
FTaylor Charles BJackson
WR:
Fitzgerald SMoss Cotchery Moore Nicks Bennett JJones
TE: Winslow
Shockey PK:
Kaeding Folk JBrown
DT: Giants
Colts
|
Overall strategy:
Adjust to today. Forget the Stud RB philosophy that has been
unsuccessful for me in
FanEx. It's fine within a common
group, but not in this I-May-Know-More-Than-You FanEx league.
Strongest
position overall: Hmmm..
I think things are pretty balanced between passers and runners.
Any time you have Brees and Turner, you are likely looking
toward qualifying for the playoffs. However, FAD has
no
playoffs. It's win or lose only. Overall, I actually like the TE
group best., as I expect good things from the full
of
personality Winslow/Shockey duo.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): Again,
from my bias view, they seem balanced to me. WRs have few stars
and many gambles among the seven players.
Your
best move or pick of the draft: I
traded 10 of my 20 original draft slots. My favorite was gaining
an extra third rounder to secure RB2 Mareno. At a time when
runners were scarce, it was important to gain both Brees and him
in the same round.
Your proudest moment: Gaining a second
first round slot art a reasonable cost and claiming the popular
WR Fitzgerald at 1.11.
The worst
pick or move of the draft: Davis's
Cowboy trio puzzles me. I could understand the Barber/Jones
pairing, but Why-Oh-Why invest any thing in RB3 Tashard Choice?
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? I'm
going to kick their tails, but... The Rito/Nazarek
roster is my favorite. From Warner to Ravens, it looks good and
tight - Just as those guys like 'em.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Chris
Rito | Mike Nazarek
QB: Warner
Hasselbeck Collins RB:
Westbrook Addai Parker CTaylor Betts
WR: AJohnson Colston Boldin Chambers Morgan Galloway
TE: Daniels Miller
PK: Elam Vinitieri
DT: Ravens Vikings |
|
Overall
strategy: Our
strategy was simply to take the most valuable player at
every pick, regardless of position or “need.” While
not eschewing the “Stud RB Theory”, we also are
believers in amassing multiple top-end WRs in a league
with PPR and a lineup requirement of 3-4 WRs. Third, we
always try to get three
NFL starting QBs to give us a depth edge over at least
half of the league. Finally, for our bench players
we
also like to try to get a single explosive, “boom or
bust” player for occasional outbursts which are uber-
valuable in the “best ball” scoring format.
Strongest
position overall: Despite
waiting a long time for our #4, we are quite pleased
with our WRs and would venture a guess that we will get
more points from our WRs than will any other team.
Boldin, Colston
and Andre Johnson each could and should finish in the
top 10 this season and we could total 300 catches
and 4000 yards between them. We have a possible TD
machine in Chambers and some explosive weekly scoring
potential in
Galloway
.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K): Many will
question our RB strategy since there is potential for
Addai and Parker to be in significant time shares with a
rookie or an unproven soph. There is
risk here, but we are less concerned than most with
those projections. It is possible that we have numerous
RB#4 and no real RB#2 in the worst case scenario; with
the injury risk of Westbrook, this could leave us in a
precarious position some weeks.
Your
best move or pick of the draft:
The best pick might be Anquan Boldin in the 4th
round. He was the
top WR in points-per-game and finished 6th
overall despite missing four games with an ugly injury.
Many
shied away in fear of where he might end up playing, but
the guy should again put up monster numbers, and
we were able to get him as our 3rd WR which
should give us a huge edge over many competitors. This
also
set off a spending spree at WR which allowed some RBs to
fall to us that perhaps might not have fallen otherwise.
Your
proudest moment: There were several times we zigged
when others thought we would zag. In this
sort of automated draft, its always fun to see
someone’s “predraft” label disappear after you
draft, because
that means that someone thought there was no way we
would take “their guy”. Its almost like
hearing
someone cuss after you make a pick in a live draft LOL.
Drafting with a partner, the best moments are
usually internal when one of us gets to say “I told
you so” when we wait on a guy and still get him later.
The
worst pick or move of the draft:
Perhaps taking Owen Daniels in the 8th
round. We really like Daniels in the PPR, but the next
guy on our list (Chris Cooley) was still available two
rounds later. Also, our sleeper
fav Kevin Boss had the same bye week as Daniels so we
couldn’t take him as a backup. We also took Hasselbeck
in the late 9th round and perhaps we could
have got comparable value later. We also took a fair
number of guys with injury risks and/or history.
If
you had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Probably
Duane Cahill’s roster, since it
doesn’t have any obvious weaknesses and also has the
potential to have several top scorers. Everyone
has
a weak spot, and his WRs will not be as powerful as
some….but he should have some good PPR guys and
if
Burress plays somewhere DC will be fine. He does have
some very good depth at RB with multiple
underrated TD scorers, and a superstar super-dependable
QB. A top
end TE and even the first couple of kickers off the
board...solid team. Duane is a multiple-FAD
champion, so I will also pay homage to his
strength in this format. |
=================================================================================== |
|
|
Brian
Hulett
QB: Ryan
Bulger Redman RB:
Gore McFadden Stewart McClain Faulk
WR: Jennings Marshall
Henderson Coles Camarillo Jenkins
TE: Cooley Heap
PK: Dawson Rackers
DT: Bears Titans |
Overall
strategy:
One-time FAD champ seeks return to same via selecting solid
players at every
opportunity. ADP, VBD, and other drafting strategies
overrated.
Strongest
position overall: WR.
No superstars, but every one of my six-man receiving squad
should be productive all year long, especially in our PPR
format, although Marshall & Camarillo still have some
injury issues to fight back from.
Weakest
position overall (excluding D/ST and K):
You might expect RB, but I have faith in McFadden to prove his
worth this year in a big way, so I'd say TE is my weak spot.
Cooley only scored once last year and Heap is an injury-riddled
shadow of his former self who blocks more than I'd like;
however, Cooley's 83
catches last year, again, are huge in our PPR scoring.
Your
best move or pick of the draft:
We won't know this for a few months, now, will we? But at
this point, writing in June, it looks like drafting Kevin Faulk
in the 14th round might be my biggest steal. <broken
record> Our format is "best ball," with the highest
scorers at each position chosen automatically, so I don't have
to anticipate when he'll catch 8 for 80 and a score, and he'll
do that once or twice, thereby scoring like a 3rd-rounder at
worst....occasionally.
Your proudest moment: Run, DMc!
The worst
pick or move of the draft:
Heap as backup TE. Thanks for the memories, Todd.
If you
had to, with whom would you switch rosters and why? Ian
Allan...because he's won this
monster two years in a row and
knows something I don't. He traded out of the first round
and will probably win it again. However, looking at the
rosters through my own eyes and not looking over my shoulder at
Ian, my old friend Matt Pitzer has a tasty-looking group lined
up, although his wideouts include always-injured Branch and that
bizarre Raiders first-round rookie.
=================================================================================== |
|
|
|